J Ayub Med Coll Abbottabad;16(2)
AUDIT OF LEIOMYOMA UTERUS AT KHYBER TEACHING HOSPITAL
Shamshad Begum, Sameera Khan
Department of Obstetrics and Gynaecology, Ayub Medical College & Teaching Hospital,
Abbottabad
Background: Fibroid is the commonest tumor of the
reproductive tract and frequently encountered problem in gynecological
practice. This study was carried out to observe the frequency of fibroids in
relation to age, parity and clinical manifestations along with a critical
review of its management. Methods:
This study was carried out over a period of one year from 1st January to 31st
December 2000 in Gynae “A” unit of Khyber teaching hospital, Peshawar. All
patients presenting with fibroid uterus were included in the study. Data
collection included age, parity, menstrual pattern, presenting symptoms,
medical and surgical treatment history. Diagnostic criteria were clinical and ultrasonography. Evaluation of medical treatment and
surgery were carried out. Management outcome of minimal invasive surgery was
also observed. Results and Conclusion: Total
146 cases were observed. Greater frequency was found in late reproductive and perimenopausal years (65.7%). There were 34.2% cases in
reproductive age group. Majority was multiparous
(72%) and 28% were nulliparous. Infertility was
noticed in 16%. Myomas were mostly symptomatic (70%).
Menstrual symptoms were commonest (81.5%), pain was second common symptom
(27.3%). About 24% presented with abdominal mass and hyaline degeneration were
in 50% of cases. Leiomyomas were multiple in 63.1%
and commonest variety was interstitial (60.4%). Familial factor noticed in
5.4%, clinical diagnosis was made in 58.2% of cases, while ultrasound was used
in 40.4% of patients, conservative treatment was given in 37.6% including
medical therapy (8.2%), Surgery was performed in (62.3%). .Myomectomy
(10.2%) and hysterectomy was carried out in 52.05%. Minimal invasive surgery
was not possible in our set up.
KeyWords: Leiomyoma, menorrhagia, degenration, myomectomy, hystrectomy, Fibroid uterus
INTRODUCTION
Leiomyomas are the commonest tumors in female genital tract and
in the body as a whole. These benign tumors of smooth muscles occur in 20-30%
females of reproductive age group1 and tend to be symptomatic. Their
growth is considered to be dependent upon estrogens excess,2 as leiomyomas contain more estrogen receptors than normal
myometrium3,4 and they usually regress after menopause.
They are asymptomatic in more than 50% of
cases, the most important clinical manifestation is menorrhagia
(in 30% of cases), Dysmenorrhoea, abdominal pain,
mass, pressure symptoms, infertility and repeated miscarriages may be the
presenting symptoms. Bimanual pelvic examination is more revealing where
uterine size, consistency, contours and mobility can be easily assessed. Ultrasonography is a simple diagnostic modality for
leiomyomas.5 Hysterosalpingogram, magnetic
resonance imaging, (MRI) computed tomography, hysteroscopy and endohyesterosonography are other important diagnostic aids.6,7
Management is either conservative or
surgical. Conservative treatment is used where myomas
are asymptomatic, not leading to complications and in menopausal patients with
the hope of spontaneous regression. Surgical treatment includes hysterectomy, myomectomy and minimally invasive surgery. Hysterectomy is
the traditional surgical treatment for leiomyomas. Myomectomy involves removal of myoma
while conserving the uterus for future reproductive capability. It gives good
results and 50% pregnancy rate.8 While symptoms improvement is
75-80%.9 The relative morbidity of myomectomy
has been reported greater than hysterectomy8, specially intraperitoneal bleeding and febrile morbidity. Recurrence
rate of leiomyoma is 30% after myomectomy.10
New techniques involve shorter and comfortable recovery, less disfigurement,
short hospital stay and financial savings. These are laparoscopic myomectomy, hysteroscopic submuc-ous myomectomy and myoma coagulation. Hystero-scopic
resection and myoma coagulation are performed as out
patient procedures.
The alternative of surgery is medical
treatment e.g. Gonadotrophin releasing hormone
analogues (GnRHa). A 20-50% decrease in myoma size occurs within three months treatment,11
but due to reversal of tumor size to pre treatment size after stopping therapy
and post menopausal symptoms has limited wide spread use of GnRHa
analogues. The objectives of this study were to observe the frequency of
fibroid in relation to age and parity, clinical manifestations and critical
review of its management.
MATERIAL AND METHODS
This study was
carried out in Gynae ‘A’ unit of Khyber teaching
hospital, Peshawar. All cases of leiomyoma uterus encountered
between 1st January and 31st December 2000 were included in this study. A total
of 146 women with diagnosis of leiomyoma were seen.
Detailed history and clinical examination was performed in all cases. About 100
of those were admitted through out patient clinic and rest were reassured or
given medical treatment. Data collection included age, parity, menstrual
pattern current and previous, presenting symptoms, medical and surgical
history. Diagnostic criteria were based on clinical examination and ultrasonography. Those put on medical therapy were followed
by serial ultrasonic measurements of fibroids. Those admitted in ward were
either given conservative treatment where myomas were
associated with pregnancy or subjected to surgical treatment. All routine
investigations and preparations were carried out. Myomectomy
was performed in cases where fibroids were the cause for infertility while few
other patients were advised to take a chance for conception. Husband semen
analysis and tubal patency
were checked in all cases where myomectomy was
performed. After surgery all the removed leiomyomas
and uteri with or without adnexae were examined
macroscopically and were sent for histopathology as well. Morbidity was
assessed in all cases and all were followed in out patient clinic later on.
Results
Table-1:
Symptoms (n=146)
Symptoms |
No of Cases |
% |
Menstrual abnormality |
119 |
81. 5 |
a. Menorrhagia |
52 |
35.6 |
b.Intermenstrual bleeding |
19 |
13.00 |
c. Continous bleeding |
8 |
5.40 |
d Dysmenorrhoea |
40 |
27.30 |
Postmenupausal bleeding |
3 |
2.05 |
Post coital bleeding |
6 |
4.10 |
Blood stained discharge |
3 |
2.00 |
Pain |
40 |
27.30 |
Pressure symptoms |
26 |
17.00 |
Mass abdomen |
36 |
24.00 |
Urinary retention |
1 |
0.60 |
Infertility |
24 |
16.10 |
Pain associated with pregnancy |
6 |
4.10 |
A total of 146 cases of leiomyoma
uterus were seen during the study period. The greater frequency was found
between 30-50 years age group (50 cases 34.2%). The majority of patients were parous 105 cases (72%) and perimenopausal.
Nulliparous were 41 cases (28%). The familial
frequency of leiomyoma was 5.4%. This could be
coincidental finding due to common nature of leiomyomas.
The frequency of symptomatic myomas was 70% while
asymptomatic were 30% this means majority present with symptoms. The symptoms
have been summarized in table-1. The rest of results have been summarized in
tables2-6.
Table-2: Number
and types of fibroids
No.
of fibroid |
No. of
cases |
% |
Single |
38 |
36.8 |
Multiple |
65 |
63.1 |
Type of fibroid |
||
Interstitial |
55 |
60.4 |
Subserous |
7 |
7.6 |
Submucous |
20 |
21.0 |
Fbroid Polyp |
9 |
9.8 |
Discussion
Multiparous patients were found to have fibroids more frequently
than nulliparous in their perimeno-pausal
years which shows their characteristics slow growth rate. Infertility with leiomyoma is a definite factor in 2-10% of cases.12
Which is quite comparable with our study where infertility was found to be 11%.
The most common
manifestation was menorrhagia. Increased vascularity, altered uterine contractility and increased
endometrial surface area lead to excessive blood loss. A 30% incidence of abdominal
pain is reported13 due to degenerative changes. Our observation also
revealed abrupt pain of severe intensity due to degenerative changes among
fibroids. Carneous dgeneration
occurs in 8% of tumors with pregnancy.14 Hyaline degeneration was
commonest degeneration noticed and reported incidence is 60 %.15
Calcification was found in subserosal myomas in patients well beyond menopause. Degeneration
usually occurs in old mature tumors which needs careful evaluation to rule out
malignant degeneration.
Diagnosis
of myomas was mostly clinical because of
characteristic nature of tumor. Ultrasonography is
the most useful confirmatory method with 80% accuracy. Computed tomography and
Magnetic resonance imaging can not be used as routine tests because of high
cost. Regarding management of fibroids, expectant management in asymptomatic,
incidentally diagnosed and menopausal patients was useful but watchful waiting
requires frequent consultations and follow-up with ultrasonography.
Non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs
(NSAIDS ) decrease menstrual flow by 20 to 30 % in menorrhagia16 but
response is less consistent with myomas as our study
revealed effective relief of dysmenorrhoea and 20%
relief of menorrhagia. So NSAIDS can help where
conservative management is selected.
Table-3:
Secondary changes in leiomyomas
Type
of degeneration |
No.
of cases |
% |
Hyaline degeneration |
46 |
50 |
Cystic degeneration |
5 |
5.4 |
Septic degeneration |
8 |
8.7 |
Carneous degeneration |
4 |
4.0 |
Calcification |
6 |
6.5 |
Myxomatous degeneration |
Nil |
0.0 |
Sarcomatous degeneration |
Nil |
0.0 |
Table-4: Method
of diagnosis
Method |
No. of cases |
% |
Clinical examination |
85 |
58.2 |
Ultrasonography |
59 |
40.4 |
Laproscopy |
2 |
1.3 |
per-operative |
3 |
2.0 |
Table-5:
Management of leiomyomas
Type of management |
No. of cases |
% |
Conservative |
55 |
37.6 |
a. Re-assurance |
43 |
29.0 |
b. Medical therapy |
12 |
8.2 |
Surgical procedure |
91 |
62.3 |
Myomectomy |
15 |
10.2 |
Hystrectomy |
76 |
52.05 |
Table-6: Post
operative morbidity
Type
of morbidity |
No of cases |
% |
Total Morbidity |
28 |
30.7 |
a. Fever |
8 |
28.0 |
b. Wound sepsis |
2 |
7.1 |
c. Urinary tract infection |
10 |
35.7 |
d. Anemia |
3 |
10.7 |
e. Prolong hospital stay |
5 |
17.8 |
The role of contraceptives in controlling menorrhagia with fibroids is satisfactory16 but
degeneration and infarction can occur therefore careful medical supervision is
need. The use of progesterone in our study was limited to patients with
excessive bleeding awaiting surgery as recent studies suggest role of
progesterone in pathogenesis of myomas.17,18 Our experience also
supports increase in myoma size with progesterone. Danazole decreases myoma size
with three months therapy16 but our study didn’t reveal satisfactory
decrease in myoma size with three months Danazole and ultrasound follow-up. Its role in myoma regression has been inconsistent and lacks patients
satisfaction because of androgenic side effects.
GnRha cause 30 to 50 % reduction in myoma size16,19 by producing hypoestrogenic
state and cause pseudomenopause. Reversal of myoma size to its pretreatment size (88%) within three
months of discontinuation therapy is a major disadvantage.16 Our
experience with GnRha is less satisfactory because of
its high cost, poor follow-up concept of patient and inability to wait till
satisfactory improvement occurs.
Symptomatic myomas
usually need surgery. Myomectomy is recommended in
reproductive age where fertility is mainly concerned. It gives 50% pregnancy
rate20 and 75% subjective relief of menorrhagia.
Though myomectomy is associated with higher morbidity
than hystrectomy21 but by experienced surgeons it compares favorably
to hysterectomy.22 Our study found it to be a safe procedure and its
morbidity was equal to that of hysterectomy. Febrile morbidity was found to be
surprisingly low and overall transfusion rate was not higher than other major
procedures. Mechanical haemostasis with tourniquet
was quite satisfactory. Laproscopic myomectomy is less invasive but technical difficulties,
hemorrhage, perforation, fluid imbalance, prolong operating time and failure to
complete proposed surgery disfavors it as routine procedure. In our setup it
has not gained value as cosmetic surgery as our patients are not cosmetically
conscious and enough cosmetic safety of Pfannensteil
incision is better then multiple portals of entry for laproscopic
surgery. Satisfactory closure of serosal surface is
difficult laproscopically23 which leads to post-operative adhesions.
Complications rate is 31%24 the substantial benefit of laproscopic surgery are reduced postoperative pain, faster
recovery and short hospital stay but myomas more than
six cm in size and more than four in number require abdominal approach.25
Hyesteroscopic is less invasive but hazardous due to
limited exposure and difficulty in controlling bleeding. It cures menorrhagia in submucous myomas unto 90 % and pregnancy rate of 64 % is reported.
Our audit reveals preference of abdominal myomectomy as compared to endoscopic procedures because importance of adequate exposure can not be overemphasized and it enables surgeons to feel for smaller inconspicuous myomas that might otherwise be missed. Hysterectomy was found to be treatment of choice for perimenupausal patients and was found more effective to give complete symptom relief. Prevention of carcinoma by removing cervix and endometrium and easing future estrogen replacement therapy without endometrial cavity monitoring favored hysterectomy as management option for myomas. Although hystrectomy has morbidity rate of 42/10020 but improvement of general heath, correction of anemia, prophylactic antibiotic therapy, optimum sterilization, good homeostasis, good analgesia and early mobility greatly reduces its morbidity. Our morbidity with hysterectomy was quite low than reported rate. Depression, anxiety and sexual dysfunction can occur with hysterectomy which can be avoided by proper pre-operative counseling, good understanding of symptoms and medical advice.
CONCLUSION
Leiomyomas are found frequently in late reproductive and perimenupausal years. Ultrasonography
is most simple and effective diagnostic tool. Expectant treatment is only
helpful in asymptomatic myomas. Medical treatment
does not give complete cure and gives partial symptom relief till definite
treatment is decided. The definite treatment is surgery. Conventional surgery
though old fashioned gives direct approach and good results.
1.
Brandly JP. Uterine
fibroids “What every women should know, treatment choices for benign uterine
conditions. www.Obgyn.neta services of Elecon corp.
2.
Benangiano G, Cronje H, Kivinen ST. BeZoladex (goserelin acetate) and
anemic patient: results of a multicentre fibroid
study. Fertility and sterility Amer J 1996;66:223-8
3.
Rein MS, Barbieri
RL, Friedman AJ. Progesterone: A critical role in pathogenesis of uterine myomas. Am J Obst Gynecol 1995;172(1)14-8.
4.
Smith SK. Regulation of fibroid growth: time
for a rethink? Br J Obst Gynaecol
1993;100:977-8.
5.
Mayer DP, Shipilov
V. Ultrasonography and Magnetic resonance imaging of
uterine fibroids. Clin North America 1995;22:667-703
6.
Dinaro FG, Bratta F, Romano F, Caradonna P.
The diagnosis of benign uterine pathology using transvaginal
endohysterosnography. In: Clinical Experiences in
Obstetrics Gynecology 33rd edition. 1996.pp103-07
7.
Bernard JP, Lecuru
F, Darles C, Robin F, Taurelle
R. Saline contrast sonohysterography as first-line
investigation for women with uterine bleeding. Utrasound
in Obstet Gynecol
1997:10:121-5.
8.
Thompson JD, Rock JA. Leiomyomata
uteri and myomectomy. In: Te Linde's
operative gynecology, 8th edition, Lippincort -Raven
publishers 1997 pp.731-91.
9.
Kazamel MD. Medical and
socioeconomic impact of uterine fibroids. Obst gynae clinics 1995;22:625-35
10. Frances
Jr H. Abdominal myomectomy
as a treatment for symptomatic uterine fibroids. Obstetrics and gynecology
clinics North-America 1995;22(4):781-9.
11. Rutgers
Jl, Spong CY, Sinow R, Heiner J. Leuprolide Acetate treatment and myoma
arterial size. Obst Gynecol
Amer J 1995;86 (3): 386-8.
12. Wallach EE, Vu KK. Uterine fibroids, Myomata
uteri and infertility. Clinics of North America 1995; 22:791-9
13. Hutchins
Jr FL. Uterine fibroids; Diagnosis and indications
for treatment. Obs and Gyn
Clinics of North America 1995;22(4):659- 64
14. Scot
JR. Disorders of uterine corpous. In: Danforth obstetrics and gynaecology.
7th Edition, Parker publisher 1995; pp929.
15. Prayson RA, Hart WR. Pathologic considerations of uterine
smooth muscles tumors. Clin N America 1995;22(4):637-57
16. Davis
KM, Schlaff WD. Medical management of uterine fibromyomata. Clin N America 1995;22(4): 727-37
17. Harrison
M, Woolrych BM, Robinson R. Fibroid growth in
response to high dose progestogen. Fertility and
sterility American journal 1995;64(1):191-2.
18. Reinsch RC, Murphy AA, Morales AJ, Yen SSC. The effect of
RU 486 and Leuprolide acetate on uterine artery blood
flow in fibroid uterus. Am J obstet gynecol 1994;170(6)1623-6.
19. Lumsden MA, West CP, Thomas E, Coutts J, Hillier H.
Treatment with gonando trephine releasing hormone
agonist "Goserelin" before hysterectomy for
uterine fibroids. British journal of obstetrics and gynecology 1997;101:438-42.
20. Al-Taher H, Farquharson RG.
Management of uterine fibroids. Br J Hosp Med 1993;50(2/3):133-6.
21. Neuwirth RS. Hysteroscopic submucous myomectomy. Obstet and Gynecol Clinics of
North-America 1995;22(3):541-58
22. Iverson
Jr RE, Chelmow D, Strohbehn K, Waldman L. Relative morbidity of abdominal
hysterectomy and myomectomy for management of uterine
leiomyomas. Obst gynecol 1996;88(3):415- 9.
23. Scott
JR, Disaia PJ, Surgical treatment of leiomyomas. In: Danforth
obstetrics an gynecology. 7th edition, Parker publisher 1995;pp 830-4.
24. SmithDC, Donohue LR, Waszak SJ. A
hospital review of advanced gynecologic endoscopic procedures.
American J Obstet gynecol
1994;170(6):1635-42.
25. Mais V, Ajossa S, Guerriero S. Mascia M.
Laparoscopic versus abdominal myomectomy, A
prospective randomized trial to evaluate benefits in early outcome. American J Obstet Gynecol 1996;174(2):654-8.
Address for Correspondence:
Dr.
Shamshad Begum, Assistant Professor, Department of Obstetrics and Gynaecology,