A
TWO YEARS AUDIT OF COMPLICATIONS OF HYSTERECTOMY AT AYUB TEACHING HOSPITAL
ABBOTTABAD
Rubina Bashir, Zahida Parveen, Ruqqia Sultana,
Bushra Khan
Department of Gynaecology,
Background: Hysterectomy is one of the most common major surgical procedures performed in Gynaecology. Our objective was to determine the operative and postoperative complications of this procedure with an aim to improve management at our unit. Methods: This study was conducted in the Department of Gynaecology, Ayub Teaching Hospital, Abbottabad form January 2002 to December 2003. Indications, complications and mortality associated with hysterectomy were assessed. Results: Total number of hysterectomies performed in two years at our unit was 316. Major Indications for hysterectomies were dysfunctional uterine bleeding (38%) and fibroid uterus, (27%) followed by prolapse (22%). Complications developed in 14% out of these. The frequency of complications was related with indication for hysterectomy, age, parity and history of associated serious illness. It was found that frequency of complications in fibroid uterus was higher (1.2%) than that for Dysfunctional uterine bleeding (DUB) (1.0%). There was no operative death, while 5 (1.5%) patients died within 2 weeks of surgery. Conclusion: We have a fairly high frequency of morbidity and mortality associated with hysterectomy. In order to reduce these proper selection, pre-operative preparation and less invasive alternative treatment for the commonest indications of hysterectomy (that is fibroids and DUB) for example various methods of endometrial ablation or resections can be employed.
Keywords: Hysterectomy, Complications, morbidity, dysfunctional uterine
bleeding
INTRODUCTION
Hysterectomy is
currently the most common major elective procedure in the world, with more than
70,000 Hysterectomies performed annually in
MATERIAL AND
METHODS
This study was carried out at Gynaecology unit’C’ of Ayub Teaching Hospital Abbottabad form January 2002 to December 2003. Patients received in outdoor Department with Fibroids, DUB, endometriosus, Ademomyosis, Prolapse, pelvic mass and chronic Pelvic Inflammatory Disease (OID) were admitted in the indoor department for Hystrectomy. Preoperative information included relevant past medical history and information regarding previous gynaecological management. Baseline investigations, included Blood Group to Rh factor, Hemoglobin estimation, urine routine examination, blood sugar, X-ray chest, ECG and an abdominopelvic ultrasound were done. Majority of the patients were found to be anaemic, correction of anemia with blood transfusions and haematinics prior to surgery was done.
Any other associated disease eg infections, diabetes mellitus, hypertension etc. were treated, in collaboration with medical team. Operative information included the details of operative procedure, operative findings and complications. Post operative complications were documented and patients were discharged between 5th-7th post operative day, after receiving the histopathology report. Out patient follow-ups were done fortnightly for six weeks.
We investigated the operative and post operative complications and its relation with indication for hysterectomy, age, parity, general physical health prior to surgery, use of prophylactic preoperative and postoperative antibiotics. Method of hysterectomy, expertise and grade of surgeon. Complications encountered intra-operatively were haemorrhage, damage ot surrounding structures.
Antibiotic coverage was given to all patients (100%) prophylactic single pre-operative dose of antibiotic half an hour prior to surgery definitely decreased the incidence of infections.
Post-operative complications were categorized into early (during the stay in hospital) and late (after discharge). Early post-operative complications included Anemia, wound infections, haematoma formation, Urinary tract infection (UTI), Chest infection, Deep Vein Thrombosis(DVT), pulmonary embolism, secondary haemorrhage myocardial infaraction, bladder damage, fistula formation and death late complications included, secondary haemorrhage, withdrawal symptoms in patients under going oophorectomy included hotflushes, anxiety, depression and mood change.
RESULTS
A total of 316 hysterectomies were carried out in a period of two years at Gynae ‘C’ unit of Ayub teaching Hospital, Abbottabad. Out of these 278 (88%) were total abdominal hysterectomies while the rest (22%) were Vaginal hysterectomies. Out of these 60% of hysterectomies were carried out by consultants and 40% were done by Senior Medical Officers under supervision. The results of this study are summarized in tables 1-4.
Table-1: Distribution of patients according to age
groups (n=316)
Age Group |
Cases (%) |
20-29 |
9 (2.84%) |
30-39 |
125 (39.55%) |
40-49 |
143 (45.25%) |
50-59 |
22 (6.9%) |
>60 |
60 (18.98%) |
All Age groups |
n=316 |
Table -2: Indications for hysterectomy
Indications for
Hysterectomy |
Cases (%) |
DUB |
120 (38%) |
Fibroid Uterus |
81 (27%) |
Endometriosis/ Adenomyosis |
20 (6%) |
Prolapse |
71 (22%) |
Pelvic mass |
14 (4%) |
Others |
10 (3%) |
Table-3: Complications of hysterectomy (n=316)
Complications |
Cases (%) |
Wound infection |
13 (4.11%) |
UTI/Chest infection |
8 (2.53%) |
Haematoma |
4 (1.26%) |
Deep Vein Thrombosis |
8 (2.53%) |
Pulmonary Embolism |
4 (1.26%) |
Secondary haemorrhage |
3 (0.94%) |
Bladder Injury |
2 (0.62%) |
Intestinal Damage |
2 (0.62%) |
Total |
44 (13.92%) |
The rate of complications was found to be higher in vaginal than abdominal procedure. Visceral damage included damage to intestines and bladder injury which were detected during surgery and repaired mostly in cases with endometriosis pelvic inflammatory disease or previous pelvic surgery in which dense adhesion were present. Highest frequency of post operative complications was infections either related to wound (4%) urinary tract infection or chest infection (2.5%). 5 patients died (a mortality rate of 15.8 per thousand). 1 died in the operation theatre during the recovery phase of Anaesthesia (cardiac assert) (0.3) remaining 4 died in the post operative period causes being pulmonary (0.6) embolism, septicemia (0.3) and myocardial infaraction (0.3)
Table-4: Causes of mortality (n=316)
Mortality |
Cases (% ) |
Cardiac Arrest |
1 (0.31 %) |
Pulmonary embolism |
2 (0.62%) |
Septicemia |
1 (0.31%) |
Myocardial Infarction |
1 (0.31%) |
Total Mortality |
5 (1.5%) |
DVT was found to be more common in anaemic obese or reluctant to ambulate patients. Frequency of withdrawal symptoms in cases with removal of ovaries was almost 80% and mostly needed psychological support and hormone replacement therapy in carefully selected cases.
DISCUSSION
This study indicates that the highest frequency of hystrectomy was for DUB followed by fibroid uterus. Operative complications were seen more commonly in cases of fibroid uterus as compared to DUB. Haemorrhage being the major complication encountered in these cases as also indicated by other studies.
The frequency of visceral damage (0.5-2%) corresponds to other reported studies on rate of visceral damage.4 Mortality rate of 1.6% in our study group was comparable to other large cohort studies which ranged from 0.5 - 1.6 per thousand.5,6 To reduce the number of hysterectomy and associated complications less invasive alternate treatment methods can be tried. For fibroid uterus thousands of women world wide have undergone the procedure of uterine artery artery embolization and have found the result to be worthy of comment.8 Monthly administration of GnRH agonist significantly reduces the size of uterine leiomyoma.9 GnRH agonist therapy induces the reduction of gonadal oestrogen, growth factors and blood flow, which are required for the growth of fibroid.
There is now an increasing number of non surgical alternatives to hysterectomy particularly for abnormal uterine bleeding and since this is the indication for hysterectomy in at least one third of cases recent treatment advances could bring the Hystrectomy rates down still further.10
Microwave indometrial ablation is an established treatment for DUB.11 Several second generation endometrial ablation treatments have been performed under local anaesthetic including thermal balloon, monopolar diathermy and hydro-thermal ablation techniques.
Gynaecologists are also again beginning to favour subtotal hysterectomy with its less complication rate and less risk of impaired sexual function.13 Particularly when combined with the removal of transformation zone which minimizes the risk of cervical cancer. The higher incidence of infection rate is caused by contamination from vagina.14 To lessen the spill of vaginal bacteria into operative site a vaginal douche and thorough bath with hexachlorophene or povidine-iodine, the evening before surgery and thorough cleaning of vagina in the operation room is recommended. 15
REFERENCES
1.
Maresh MJA, MetCalfe MA, McPherson K. The value national hysterectomy
study: description of the patients and their surgery. Br J Obstet Gynaecol
2002;109:302-12
2.
Pherson KMC, Metcalfe MA, Herbert A. Severe complications for
hysterectomy; the VALUE study. Br J Obstet Gynaecol 2004;111:688-94
3.
Harkki-Siren P, Sjoberg J, Toivonen J, Tiitinen A. Clinical outcome and
tissue trauma after laparosocopic and abdominal Hystrectomy. Acta Obstet
Gynecol Scand 2000:79:866-71.
4.
Drutz HP, Main Prize TC. Unrecognized small vesico vaginal fistula as
cause of persistant urinary incontinence. Am J Obstet Gynecol 1988;158:237-40.
5.
Loft A,
6.
Roos NP. Hystrectomies in one
7.
Walker W, Washington-Kirsch RL. Fatal Septicaemia after Fiberoid
embolisation. Lancet 1999: 354:1730
8.
9.
Friedman AJ, Barbieri RL, Benacerraf BR, Schieff I. Treatment of
ceiomzomata with intranasal or sub cutaneous leuprolide, a gonadotropin -
releasing hormone agonist. Fertil Steril 1987;48: 560-4.
10. Coulter A, McPhersonk, Vessey
M. British women undergo too many or too few hysterectomies. Soc Sci Med
1988;27:987-94.
11. Wallage S, Cooper KG, Graham
WJ, Parkin DE. A randomised trial comparing local versus general anaesthesia
for microwave endometrial abalation. Br J Obstet Gynaecol 2003;110:799-807
12. Hawe JA. Cavaterm thermal
balloon ablation for the treatment of memorhagia. Br J Obstet Gynaecol 1999;106:1143-8.
13. Sutton C. Subtotal hystrectomy
revisited. End surgery 1995;3:105-8.
14. Boyd ME. Practical Gynaecology
Surgery: Principles in practice. Baltimose: Urban and Sctwastenbury. 1990.
15. Rock JA, Thompson JD. Te Linde's
operative Gynaecology 8th edition.
_____________________________________________________________________________________________
Address For Correspondence:
Dr Rubina Bashir,
Department of Obstetrics & Gynaecology,